Board Performance · 2024
In this section14 topics
- Compliance Monitoring — Overview2 items
- Prevention of Conflicts of Interest3 items
- Prevention of the Use of Inside Information3 items
- Anti-Corruption4 items
- Whistleblowing3 items
- Selection of Directors & Chief Executives6 items
- Selection of Independent Directors3 items
- Director Development1 item
- Evaluation of Board & Subcommittee Performance4 items
- Subcommittees1 item
- Meeting Attendance & Remuneration5 items
- Supervision of Subsidiaries & Associated Companies5 items
- Board Duty Performance — Overview1 item
- Audit Committee Duty Performance1 item
Compliance Monitoring — Overview
Compliance Monitoring — Introduction
Monitoring for the compliance with the corporate governance policy and operating guidelines
The company places great importance on good and transparent corporate governance. Clear policies and practices have been established to ensure that operations are conducted in accordance with good governance principles and comply with laws and international standards.
In 2024, the company closely monitored and ensured strict adherence to these policies and practices, with inspections carried out in several areas, including:
1. Maintaining Financial Credibility and Disclosure
The company places great importance on maintaining financial credibility and transparent disclosure. Various measures have been implemented to build trust among shareholders and all stakeholders, including:
(1) Preparation and Audit of Financial Statements The company prepares accurate financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. These financial statements are audited by an external auditor with internationally recognized qualifications, ensuring confidence in the accuracy and transparency of the financial information.
(2) Transparent Disclosure The company ensures the transparent disclosure of financial and other significant information through various channels, such as the annual report (56-1 One Report) and the company’s website. This allows shareholders and stakeholders to access complete and transparent information. The disclosures include performance results, financial reports, and information related to risk management practices.
(3) Compliance with Disclosure Requirements The company complies with the disclosure requirements and standards set by relevant regulatory bodies, such as the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). This ensures confidence among investors and stakeholders in the company's transparency and accountability.
(4) Risk Assessment and Monitoring The company continuously conducts financial risk assessments and monitoring to ensure that risks are managed effectively and appropriately. Results of the assessments and any corrective actions taken are reported to the board of directors and stakeholders for their awareness.
2.Conflict of Interest Prevention
The company places great importance on preventing and managing potential conflicts of interest that may arise between executives, directors, employees, and stakeholders. This is to ensure that business operations are conducted in a transparent and fair manner, while safeguarding the best interests of the company and its shareholders. The company has implemented the following measures:
(1) Conflict of Interest Prevention Policy The company has established a clear policy for preventing conflicts of interest, which requires directors, executives, and employees to disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may arise in the course of their work. They must also avoid making decisions that could impact the balance of the company's interests. This is to prevent conflicts of interest that could harm the company’s credibility and transparency. Additionally, the company has disclosed its conflict of interest prevention policy on its website to ensure that shareholders and stakeholders can access this information transparently.
(2) Disclosure of Related Interests Directors and executives with a conflict of interest in any business or contract with the company must fully disclose such information to the audit committee or the board of directors. This must undergo review and evaluation by the audit committee before being presented for approval by the board of directors. No actions that may lead to conflicts of interest will be taken until they have been properly assessed and approved.
(3) Training and Awareness Building The company provides training to directors, executives, and employees at all levels on how to be vigilant and manage conflicts of interest. This ensures that everyone understands the importance of avoiding conflicts of interest and strictly adheres to the company’s policies and regulations.
(4) Action in the Event of a Conflict In cases where a conflict of interest is identified, the company will take clear measures to address the issue by considering and making decisions in a fair manner. This may include changing the related actions or implementing disciplinary measures if necessary.
In 2024, the company has not encountered any cases that could lead to conflicts of interest.
3. Use of Insider Information for Personal Gain
The Board of Directors recognizes the importance of preventing the misuse of the company’s insider information for personal gain. As such, the company has established a policy on the trading of securities by directors, executives, and employees, which is communicated throughout the organization. This policy is also disclosed on the company's website under the "Good Governance" section. Furthermore, the company has informed executives of their responsibility to report their holdings in the company, as well as the holdings of their spouses and minor children. They are also required to report any changes in their securities holdings to the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand in accordance with Section 59 and the penalties under Section 275 of the Securities and Exchange Act B.E. 2535. In addition, the company has defined the term "Persons Designated by the Company," which refers to individuals holding positions or responsibilities who are privy to the company’s insider information (including their spouses or those living together as a couple), as well as their minor children. This also extends to any legal entities in which such individuals, their spouses, or minor children collectively hold more than 30% of the total voting rights and are the largest shareholders in the entity. These designated persons are prohibited from trading the company’s securities within 30 days before the public disclosure of quarterly and annual financial statements, as well as during any other periods designated by the company from time to time. They may only trade after the company has disclosed the relevant information, with a minimum waiting period of 24 hours following such disclosure.
In the past year, the company did not receive any complaints regarding misconduct by directors and executives related to the improper use of insider information.
4. Anti-Corruption
In 2024, the company placed great emphasis on anti-corruption efforts and promoting transparent business operations. Clear policies and practices were established to prevent and address corruption, as well as to prevent the use of personal benefits for inappropriate profit-seeking within all areas of the organization. This year, the company has rigorously implemented these policies and disclosed its anti-corruption policy on the company’s website under the "Good Governance" section, ensuring that shareholders and stakeholders can access the information transparently.
In addition, the following actions have been taken:
- Communication of Anti-Corruption Policy
- Employee Training
- Anti-Corruption Practices ex. Giving/Receiving Gifts, Souvenirs, and Hospitality, Providing and Receiving Support, Political Neutrality.
- Approval of Internal Control Adequacy by the Audit Committee
Monitoring of Compliance with Other CG Policies & Guidelines
Policy on equal disclosure of information to shareholders
1. Policy on information disclosure
1.1 In 2024, the Company disclosed important information of the Company in accordance with the requirements of listed companies, such as Form 56-1 One Report in both Thai and English via the channels of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Company's website.
1.2 In the 2024 Annual Report, the Company disclosed important information that shareholders should be aware of, such as the report on the Board of Directors' responsibilities for the financial report, presented together with the auditor's report and the management's discussion and analysis, audit fees and other service fees provided by the auditor, the list of roles and responsibilities of the subcommittees, the number of board meetings and the number of meetings attended by each director, the remuneration policy for directors and senior executives, including the form or type of remuneration.
1.3 The Company has established an investor relations unit to contact, communicate and provide information and understanding about the Company's information and operations to investors, shareholders, analysts and various agencies. It can be contacted at
2. Minimum information disclosed on the Company's website
The Company discloses important information about the Company on its website, such as Form 56-1 One Report, sustainability report, invitation letter to shareholders' meeting Shareholders' meeting report, the Company's regulations, the memorandum of association, the good corporate governance policy, the code of conduct for employees, directors and executives, and other necessary information, which are constantly updated.
According to the Corporate Governance Survey of Thai Listed Companies in 2024 by the Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD), the Company's score is at the Excellent level. However, when compared with the criteria of the Corporate Governance Report of Thai Listed Companies Survey Project and the ASEAN CG Scorecard, there are still some criteria that the Company has not yet been able to comply with, as follows:
1) The age of the directors has not been determined.
2) The board of directors' meeting has been held at least 6 times per year.
3) The subcommittees, such as the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, the Sustainability Committee, the Executive Committee, etc., have not been appointed.
However, in 2024, the Company did not commit any acts that violated the regulations of regulatory agencies, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Stock Exchange of Thailand, etc.
Prevention of Conflicts of Interest
Has the Company Acted to Prevent Conflicts of Interest?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
Prevention of Conflicts of Interest
(1) The Company has a clear and transparent shareholding structure, which prevents any potential conflicts of interest. The Company has disclosed its shareholding structure in detail in the Annual Report (Form 56-1 One Report), including a full disclosure of the Board members' securities holdings.
(2) The Board of Directors is responsible for acting according to fiduciary principles. The board evaluates the necessity and reasonableness of transactions and ensures there are no conflicts with the Company’s best interests. It monitors and oversees all activities to make sure that important information is disclosed to shareholders and investors, especially in cases where disclosure is required under the related-party transaction guidelines and/or asset acquisition or disposal.
(3) The Board of Directors has acted with caution and reasonableness, prioritizing the Company's best interests. Pricing for transactions is done in line with market prices and fair trade conditions, just as if dealing with external parties. The Company has established a system to ensure transparency and compliance with the Stock Exchange of Thailand's regulations. This has been incorporated into its corporate governance policy and ethical guidelines that directors must follow in their dealings with the Company and its shareholders.
(4) The Company requires directors with conflicts of interest to leave the meeting room and/or abstain from voting on such matters. This ensures that independent directors can freely express their opinions and cast their votes without interference. The Company Secretary will inform the meeting of any directors with conflicts of interest. After the meeting, the names and relationships of related parties, the transaction pricing, and any directors who disagree with the board’s decision (if any) will be disclosed to the Stock Exchange of Thailand within the prescribed timeline. This information will also be published on the Company’s website for transparency and recorded in the meeting minutes for future reference.
(5) If the Company decides to invest in a healthcare-related project, the Board of Directors will discuss and jointly decide on the matter, always keeping the Company's best interests in mind.
(6) The Company has disclosed information to ensure equal access to information, such as related-party transactions, and has adhered to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) announcement on the disclosure and practices of listed companies regarding related-party transactions. In 2024, the Company did not conduct any related-party transactions that violated or failed to comply with the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) or the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
Note: For the policy and procedures for preventing conflicts of interest, please read on the company website.
Number of Conflict-of-Interest Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to conflicts of interest (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Prevention of the Use of Inside Information
Has the Company Acted to Prevent the Use of Inside Information?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
Use of Insider Information for Personal Gain
- The Company has measures to prevent the unlawful use of internal information by directors, executives and employees in the department related to the information, including spouses and underage children of such persons, by prohibiting the purchase and sale, transfer and transfer of the Company’s securities within 1 month prior to the disclosure of quarterly financial statements and annual financial statements, and at least 1 day after the disclosure of such financial statements.
- The Company’s directors, executives, and relevant employees will be notified in writing of the black-out period before public disclosure of information material to changes in securities prices, in order for that information to be made public first.
- The securities holdings of the Company’s directors and executives will be disclosed in annual report and on the Company’s website. In addition, the securities holdings of the Company’s directors will be reported to the Board of Directors Meetings.
In 2024, the company secretary notified the designated persons about the blackout period, during which trading of the company’s securities is prohibited. These designated persons are restricted from trading the company's securities within 30 days prior to the disclosure of the quarterly and annual financial statements, as well as during any other periods set by the company from time to time. Trading may only be conducted after the company has disclosed the relevant information, with a minimum waiting period of 24 hours after such disclosure.
In the past year, the company did not receive any complaints regarding misconduct by directors and executives related to the improper use of insider information. Additionally, in 2024, the company organized training courses on preventing insider trading for personal gain and managing conflicts of interest. A total of 71.70% of office staff participated in the training sessions.
Number of Inside-Information Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to the use of inside information to seek benefits (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Anti-Corruption
Has the Company Acted on Anti-Corruption?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
The Company has established an anti-corruption and anti-bribery policy, which is available on the Company’s website at https://investor.rph.co.th/en/corporate-governance/anti-corruption-and-anti-bribery.
1. The Board of Directors has reviewed the Anti-Corruption Policy and established the Anti-Corruption Handbook as a guideline for all directors, executives and employees. It focuses on preventing and combating all forms of corruption, both direct and indirect, and not engaging in bribery and corruption of government and private agencies in order to gain a competitive advantage. It has also established guidelines for activities with a risk of corruption as a clear guideline for business operations and reducing the risk of corruption. Therefore, the policy has been announced within the organization and the document has been disseminated to directors, executives and employees for strict compliance.
2. After approving the policy, the management has been assigned to disseminate it to employees throughout the organization via the company’s communication channels. 100% of employees have acknowledged the policy out of all employees in the organization.
3. The Company has established a policy for reporting corruption, channels for reporting, measures to protect whistleblowers and related witnesses, as well as guidelines for verifying information reported through various channels. and report to relevant persons. In this regard, stakeholders can report information or clues about corruption in various forms as follows:
- Electronic channels: Auditcom@rph.co.th
- Postal mail: Chairman of the Audit Committee, Rajapruek Hospital, 14th floor, Mittraphap Road, Nai Mueang Subdistrict, Mueang Khon Kaen District, Khon Kaen Province
- Online channels: https://investor.rph.co.th/en/corporate-governance/whistleblowing-channel
4. Monitoring and evaluating compliance with the policy The Company has guidelines for monitoring and evaluating compliance with the anti-corruption policy. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to be responsible for continuously monitoring the implementation of the said policy to ensure that it is truly implemented and transparent. In addition, the annual audit plan of the Internal Audit Department has included corruption investigations as part of the assessment and internal audits every year to assess the risks and effectiveness of the Company's operations.
In 2024, the company has corporate governance, code of conduct, and anti-corruption activities The Company provides training on good corporate governance, business ethics, and anti-corruption to employees, as well as requiring knowledge tests through the E-Learning system to be used as a guideline for operations. The Company has provided employees with training on corporate governance, business ethics and anti-corruption, and required them to undergo testing of their knowledge through e-learning and apply such knowledge as operation practice guidelines. The no gift policy has also been announced for compliance.
Form of Anti-Corruption Operations
| Operation |
|---|
| Review of appropriateness in anti-corruption |
| Assessment and identification of corruption risk |
| The monitoring of the evaluation of compliance with the anti- corruption policy |
| Review of the completeness and adequacy of the process by the Audit Committee or auditor |
Number of Corruption Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to corruption (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Whistleblowing
Has the Company Implemented Whistleblowing Procedures?
No
Operations in the Past Year
Whistleblowing Policy
The Company’s Board of Directors provides employees and stakeholders with the opportunity to report any suspicions or complaints regarding possible violations of law, fraud, or misconduct by Company employees, as well as any behavior that could pose a risk or cause harm to the Company. This includes receiving complaints when employees or stakeholders have their rights violated or are treated unfairly. Reports can be made through the designated channels and processes established by the Company, which include measures to protect whistleblowers in a systematic and fair manner.
In 2024, the Company reviewed the Whistleblowing Policy to ensure its relevance and updated it with measures for investigating the facts, protecting reporters and whistleblowers, as well as the process for fact-checking and imposing penalties for those who violate this policy. https://investor.rph.co.th/storage/document/cg/whistle-blowing-policy-en.pdf
the Company has a Protection for Whistleblowers Employees policy or officers who report wrongdoing or complaints, provide statements, or share any information in good faith, without the intent to harm or cause damage to any individual or the company, will be protected by the company. This includes ensuring that there will be no changes in job position, duties, workplace, suspension, intimidation, interference with work performance, dismissal, or any other action that could be considered unfair treatment toward the individual. If there is a need to change or revoke the protection of any individual, approval must be obtained from the Audit Committee before taking action under this policy.
In 2024, the company did not receive any complaints concerning serious violations of corporate governance policies and business ethics by employees, nor were there any legal proceedings initiated. Additionally, there were no reports of corruption from employees or external parties.
Number of Whistleblowing Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues received through whistleblowing channels (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Selection of Directors & Chief Executives
Directors & Chief Executives — Introduction
1. Method of Selecting Individuals for Appointment as Directors and Senior Executives
• Criteria for Selecting Company Directors
1) The qualifications of the directors to be recruited must be diverse in terms of education, skills, professional expertise, and specialization that are beneficial to the Company’s business and aligned with the Company’s business strategies. There must be no discrimination based on gender, age, ethnicity, etc.
2) Must possess leadership qualities, vision, integrity, and ethics, have a transparent work history, and meet the qualifications with no disqualifying characteristics as defined by the law and Company regulations.
3) In cases where an existing director is reappointed, additional consideration will be given to the individual’s performance as a director and as a member of subcommittees during the prior term, to ensure shareholders have sufficient information for making an informed decision regarding the nominee.
4) In the case of selecting an independent director, the individual must meet the criteria set by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
• Process for Selecting Directors
1) The Board of Directors is responsible for recruiting qualified individuals to fill director positions. They present their recommendations to the Board for review, which is then proposed for approval at the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders by a majority vote, unless the position is not yet due for rotation, in which case the Board (excluding directors with a conflict of interest) selects the candidate based on a vote of at least three-quarters of the remaining directors. The newly appointed director serves the remainder of the term of the director they are replacing.
2) The Company provides an opportunity for minority shareholders to propose candidates for director positions to be considered for election.
3) The Board of Directors considers individuals for appointment based on recommendations from large and small shareholders, as well as the Director Pool from the Thai Institute of Directors (IOD).
4) The Board evaluates the skills, experience, and expertise of potential directors to ensure their qualifications align with the Company’s business strategies.
• New Director Recruitment
The Board of Directors has considered additional factors, including knowledge, expertise, and experience, which are beneficial for performing the duties of a director and necessary for strengthening the composition of the Board. The selection of executives is based on their qualifications, ethics, and character. The Company also evaluates employees' potential for future leadership roles, offering challenges and higher responsibilities to those demonstrating high performance.
In 2024, 2 independent directors requested to resign from their positions as independent directors due to their consecutive tenure of office being 9 years. The Company has given minority shareholders an opportunity to propose names of persons to be considered for election as directors to replace the original directors whose terms have expired. It appears that there were 3 shareholders who proposed names of persons to be considered for appointment as directors of the Company.
• Appointment of Directors by the Board of Directors
In the case of a director position becoming vacant for reasons other than the completion of the term, the Board of Directors appoints a qualified individual who meets all legal requirements. This appointment is presented at the next Board meeting for approval by at least three-quarters of the remaining directors. The new director serves only for the remainder of the term of the previous director unless the remaining term is less than two months.
2. Criteria for Selecting and Succession Planning for Top Executives
Selection of Top Executives The selection of top executives is proposed by the Board of Directors in accordance with the Company’s policies and business plans related to organizational restructuring, management, and staffing. This ensures that the Board, responsible for recruitment and compensation, considers candidates with the right qualifications, a good understanding of the Company’s business, and the ability to achieve the objectives and goals set by the Board. Additionally, the selected candidates must meet legal qualifications and be free from any legal disqualifications. Afterward, the proposal is presented to the Board for further consideration and appointment.
Are Directors Selected Through the Nomination Committee?
No
Are Chief Executives Selected Through the Nomination Committee?
No
Number of Directors from Major Shareholders
1
Rights of Minority Shareholders on Director Appointment
Rights of Minority Shareholders in the Appointment of Directors
• Proposing Director Nominations
The Company allows minority shareholders to propose candidates for election to the Board prior to the Annual General Meeting, according to criteria set by the Company. Shareholders are notified via the Stock Exchange news system and the Company's website. Further details can be found under the "Investor Relations" section on the Company website.
In 2024, 2 independent directors requested to resign from their positions as independent directors due to their consecutive tenure of office being 9 years. The Company has given minority shareholders an opportunity to propose names of persons to be considered for election as directors to replace the original directors whose terms have expired. It appears that there were 3 shareholders who proposed names of persons to be considered for appointment as directors of the Company.
Method of Director Appointment
| Method |
|---|
| Method whereby each director requires approval votes more than half of the votes of attending shareholders with voting rights |
Selection of Independent Directors
Introduction
Recruitment of Independent Directors
According to the Company's regulations, individuals appointed to the positions of directors and executives must meet the qualifications required by Section 58 of the Public Limited Companies Act B.E. 2535 and the Securities and Exchange Act B.E. 2535. They must also not have any disqualifications as stipulated by law. The recruitment and appointment of directors are outlined in the following details.
To align with the Company’s corporate governance policy and comply with the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Company has defined an independent director as someone who is free from any influence or interest in the Company’s operations, both directly and indirectly.
Qualifications of Independent Directors
The Board of Directors has approved the definition of "Independent Director" in accordance with the announcement of the Securities and Exchange Commission.
1) Must hold no more than 1% of the total shares with voting rights of the Company, including the parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the applicant. This also includes shares held by related persons of the independent director.
2) Must not be, or have ever been, a director involved in management, an employee, a salaried consultant, or a controlling person of the Company, parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliated companies, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the Company, unless the individual has ceased from such roles for at least two years before submitting the application to the office. This restriction does not apply to cases where the independent director has previously been a civil servant or a consultant for a government agency that is a major shareholder or controlling person of the Company.
3) Must not have a familial relationship or legal registration as a father, mother, spouse, sibling, or child, including the spouse of a child, of any other director, executive, major shareholder, controlling person, or any individual proposed to be a director, executive, or controlling person of the Company.
4) Must not have, or have ever had, any business relationship with the Company, its subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons in a way that could impede the independent exercise of judgment, nor must the individual have been a shareholder with significant influence or a controlling person of any party with a business relationship with the Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the Company. This restriction applies unless the individual has ceased from such relationships for at least two years prior to submitting the application to the office.
The business relationships referred to in the previous paragraph include regular business transactions, such as leasing or renting property, asset or service transactions, or financial assistance through lending, guaranteeing, or using assets as collateral. This includes any other similar transactions that result in liabilities requiring repayment by either party, provided that the liability amounts to at least 3% of the net tangible assets of the Company, or at least 20 million baht, whichever is lower.
The calculation of such liabilities must follow the methods for calculating the value of related party transactions as prescribed by the Securities and Exchange Commission, with similar conditions. When considering such liabilities, any debts arising within one year before establishing a business relationship with the same individual should also be included.
5) Must not be, or have ever been, the auditor of the Company, parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the Company, and must not be a shareholder with significant influence, controlling person, or partner of an auditing firm where the auditor of the Company, parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the Company is affiliated. This restriction applies unless the individual has ceased from such relationships for at least two years before submitting the application to the office.
6) Must not be, or have ever been, a provider of any professional services, including legal or financial advisory services, and must not have received more than two million baht annually in fees from the Company, parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the Company. Additionally, must not be a shareholder with significant influence, controlling person, or partner of such professional service provider. This restriction applies unless the individual has ceased from such relationships for at least two years before submitting the application to the office.
7) Must not be a director appointed to represent the directors of the Company, major shareholders, or shareholders related to major shareholders. 8) Must not be engaged in a business that is of the same nature and significantly competitive with the business of the Company or its subsidiaries. Additionally, must not be a partner with significant influence in a partnership or a director involved in managing, employed as an employee, or receiving a salary, or holding more than 1% of the total shares with voting rights of another Company that operates a business that is of the same nature and significantly competitive with the Company or its subsidiaries.
9) Must not have any other characteristics that would impair their ability to provide an independent opinion on the Company’s operations. If the Securities and Exchange Commission announces changes to the qualifications of independent directors, the Company’s independent directors must meet the new requirements in full. After being appointed as an independent director in accordance with items 1 to 9 above, independent directors may be assigned by the board to make decisions in the operations of the applicant Company, parent Company, subsidiaries, affiliates, major shareholders, or controlling persons of the applicant. Such decisions can be made in a collective decision-making manner.
In the past fiscal period, the independent directors of the Company had no business relationships or professional service relationships, nor did any individuals appointed as independent directors have, or have ever had, business relationships or professional service relationships exceeding the criteria set by the Securities and Exchange Commission regarding the approval and offering of newly issued shares.
All independent directors of the Company maintain their independence from the management and major shareholders of the Company.
In the past year 2024, the five independent directors did not have any business relationships or provide professional services in excess of the specified criteria. The five independent directors met the specified criteria, which did not affect their duties and independent opinions.
Criteria for Selecting Independent Directors
Since the Company does not have a dedicated committee for recruitment and compensation, the Board of Directors is responsible for selecting and screening individuals with the appropriate qualifications, in accordance with the Company's regulations, to ensure that professional and diverse directors are appointed. This consideration includes the structure, size, and composition of the board. The board’s recommendations are then submitted for approval, and the list of proposed directors is presented to the shareholders' meeting for election, in accordance with the established criteria. Additionally, shareholders are given the opportunity to propose candidates for the board who meet the qualifications.
Criteria for Selecting Independent Directors
As of December 31, 2024, the Company had 5 independent directors out of a total of 10 directors. These individuals were independent from the management and major shareholders of the Company. The number of independent directors met the criteria set by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which required listed companies to have independent directors constituting at least one-third of the total number of directors, but no fewer than 3. The Board of Directors was responsible for selecting and evaluating suitable candidates for appointment as directors. This process took into account recommendations from both major and minor shareholders, as well as the list of directors (Directors Pool) from trusted organizations that maintained a database of qualified individuals across various fields. Afterward, the nomination and remuneration committee evaluated the qualifications based on various criteria. The Company defined independent directors according to the announcement by the Securities and Exchange Commission as follows.
1) Criteria and Process for the Recruitment and Appointment of New Directors
In the event that a director position becomes vacant, the Board of Directors will consider recruiting a new director following appropriate and transparent criteria and processes. The considerations include the qualifications, work experience, knowledge, and expertise that are necessary but lacking in the current board. This also involves evaluating the gender diversity of the board (Board Diversity Policy), along with factors such as vision, leadership, independence, the ability to dedicate sufficient time to the Company's duties, and compliance with legal qualifications and the regulations of relevant regulatory bodies, such as the Securities and Exchange Act B.E. 2535, etc. The Board of Directors will create a Board Skill Matrix to define the necessary qualifications of directors that the Company is still lacking in terms of knowledge and expertise on the board. This is also aligned with the Company’s strategy or business objectives. For instance, if the Company plans to expand into new business areas beyond its current activities, the recruitment of new directors must consider qualifications, knowledge, expertise, and skills that match the new business direction. The board may invite candidates or names with appropriate qualifications for evaluation by the Board of Directors or the annual shareholders' meeting for further consideration and approval (depending on the case).
However, the evaluation of the qualifications of new directors or the recruitment of new directors aligns with and follows the Board Diversity Policy of the company. The Company does not limit qualifications based on gender or age. It provides an opportunity to propose directors with diverse gender and age groups, ensuring that the composition of the company's board is diverse in terms of both age and gender, promoting equality. This approach allows for unlimited information sharing, enhancing the company's competitive potential and growth.
In 2024, the Board of Directors considered the recruitment of individuals with qualifications suitable for aligning with the Company’s business operations, specifically in Audit, finance, banking, and investment. Therefore, the Board proposed and sought approval from the shareholders' meeting to increase the number of directors to ensure effective corporate governance.
2) Sources for Recruitment
The Board of Directors will recruit individuals with appropriate qualifications to serve as directors of the Company from various sources, such as recommendations or suggestions from existing Board members or external consulting firms.
For the recruitment and appointment of new directors in 2024, the Board utilized sources such as recommendations from Board members and the director database (Director Pool) from the Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) There are 4 board members.
3) Appointment of Directors at the End of Their Term
Since the Company has not yet established a nomination committee, the Board of Directors is responsible for recruiting individuals with appropriate qualifications in accordance with the relevant guidelines.
In the case where a director whose term has expired is to be reappointed for another term, the Board (excluding interested directors) will collectively assess the performance of each director during their previous term, which will be reviewed annually. This evaluation will consider meeting attendance, participation, and contributions to the Company and the board meetings, as well as the director's involvement in various activities and their relationship with the management. The findings will be summarized and presented to the Board of Directors for approval before being submitted to the shareholders' meeting for approval to reappoint the director whose term has ended.
In 2024, the Board of Directors presented for consideration at the annual shareholders' meeting the proposal to reappoint the same group of directors whose terms had expired.
Did Any Independent Director Have a Business or Professional Relationship?
No
Director Development
Development of Directors in the Past Year
Director Development, Training/Seminars/Participation in Company
Activities Director and Executive Development
The Board of Directors and executives are aware of their roles, duties, and responsibilities towards the Company. The Company places great importance on the development of human resources throughout the organization to align with the leadership and vision of the directors and executives. This development is aimed at enhancing their knowledge, skills, and potential by supporting participation in seminars and training programs that are beneficial to their duties, both internally and externally. It also includes opportunities for directors and executives to meet and exchange views with those from other organizations to bring back knowledge and experience. To further develop the Company, the following initiatives have been implemented.
1) The Board of Directors promotes and facilitates training and education for those involved in the Company's corporate governance system, such as directors, audit committee members, executives, and the Company Secretary, to continuously improve performance. Training and education can be conducted internally within the Company or by using services from external institutes.
2) The Board requires orientation for all new directors to ensure they understand the business and various operations of the Company. This prepares them to carry out their duties effectively, with the Company Secretary coordinating aspects such as business structure, board structure, scope of duties, essential laws, general business knowledge, and operational guidelines.
3) The Board has established a policy for the development of directors and executives and discloses this policy in the 2024 Annual Information Filing (Form 56-1 One Report) of the Company.
In 2024, the committee attended a seminar. Training and participating in activities of listed companies as follows:
1) Mr. Sudhon Sriyapant
- Participated in the Online Director Briefing 1/2024: ESG Integration for Sustainable seminar on April 3, 2024
- Participated in the Business Success Online Director’s Briefing 2/2024: Leading with Urgency: Climate Action for Boards seminar on September 24, 2024
2) Mr.Vallop Laopaiboon
- Participated in the Online Director Briefing 1/2024: ESG Integration for Sustainable Business Success seminar on April 3, 2024
3) Mr. Teerawat Srinakarin
- Participated in the Online Director Briefing 1/2024: ESG Integration for Sustainable Business Success seminar on April 3, 2024
- Participated in the Business Success Aspiring Directors 1/2024: Transformation: Aiming for Sustainability with Mindful Leadership seminar on February 22 2024
- Attended the Chairman Forum 2024 seminar: The Art of Chairman-CEO Dynamics: Fostering trust and Collaboration, on November 11, 2024
4) Mr. Vorathep Rangchaikul
- Attended the Audit Committee Forum 2024 seminar: Emerging Audit Standards and Implications for the Audit Committee, on July 19, 2024
- Attended the COSO Bundles & Insights of Implementation in Real Cases seminar on December 13, 2024
5) Mr. Viroj Jindamanipitak
- Attended the seminar. Audit Committee Forum 2024: Emerging Audit Standards and Implications for the Audit Committee
6) Ms. Orawan Sirirattanawong
- Attended the Audit Committee Forum 2024: Emerging Audit Standards and Implications for the Audit Committee seminar on July 19, 2024
- Attended the COSO Bundles & Insights of Implementation in Real Cases seminar on December 13, 2024
Evaluation of Board & Subcommittee Performance
Evaluation — Introduction
Performance Evaluation of the Board of Directors
The performance evaluation of the Board of Directors consists of both an overall board assessment and an individual self-assessment. Additionally, the evaluation includes the performance assessment of subcommittees, specifically the Audit Committee and the Risk Management and Governance Committee. The Board of Directors conducts an annual performance evaluation for both the Board as a whole and its subcommittees.
The Company Secretary is responsible for distributing the evaluation forms to each director, covering the overall board assessment, individual self-assessments, and subcommittee evaluations. The results are then analyzed, consolidated, and compiled, along with feedback and recommendations, for presentation and reporting to the Board of Directors. This process aims to enhance governance quality, assess the appropriateness of board composition, and improve the effectiveness of both the Board of Directors and its subcommittees.
Performance Evaluation of the Chief Executive Officer and Executives
The Board of Directors evaluates the performance of the highest-ranking executive, the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), and is also responsible for determining or approving the compensation of senior executives. The Board of Directors conducts an annual performance assessment of the CEO, focusing on predetermined goals and objectives.
This evaluation serves as a key factor in determining the CEO's annual compensation, which includes salary, bonuses, and other benefits such as healthcare coverage and annual medical check-ups. Meanwhile, the compensation of other executives and employees falls within the authority of the CEO, who establishes and oversees the executive performance evaluation policy.
Executive performance evaluations are conducted at least twice a year, specifically in June and December.
Criteria for Evaluating Board Performance
Evaluation of the Performance of the Board of Directors and the Chief Executive Officer (CEO)
1. Evaluation of the Board of Directors' Performance
The performance of the Board of Directors is regularly evaluated at least once a year and is divided into two types.
o Evaluation of the entire Board’s performance (as a whole), and
o Self-assessment of individual performance
o Additionally, the performance of the CEO is also evaluated.
The process for evaluating the performance of the Board, both as a group and individually, is managed by the Company Secretary, who is responsible for sending the evaluation forms to all directors for their assessment of the Board and the subcommittees they serve on.
The Company Secretary then collects the completed evaluation forms, compile the results, and reports them to the Board of Directors.
The Board analyzes the evaluation results and determine steps to improve the efficiency of the Board’s performance. All directors have independence in conducting their evaluations.
2) Subcommittee Evaluation
The annual performance evaluation of the subcommittees involves evaluating three areas including the structure and qualifications of the committee members, the roles, duties, and responsibilities of the committee, and the committee meetings.
The Evaluation Process
1. The performance of each subcommittee is evaluated as a whole at least once a year.
2. The Company Secretary summarizes and presents the evaluation results of each subcommittee to the Board for consideration and to determine ways to improve operational effectiveness.
Evaluation criteria range
• 90% and above > Excellent
• 70% and above > Very good
• 50% and above > Fair
• Less than 50% > Needs improvement
Evaluation of Board Performance in the Past Year
The results of the self-assessment of the Board of Directors for the year 2024 are as follows:
1) Board of Directors Evaluation Criteria
• Board Evaluation (As a Whole) score 94.02% Excellent Range
• Individual Director Evaluation score 93.88% Excellent Range
In summary, the overall results of the Board of Directors' performance evaluation for the year 2024 were rated "Excellent" in both formats including the evaluation of the entire Board and the self-assessment (directors evaluating themselves).
The Board considers these evaluation results to be beneficial for improving the efficiency of the Board's performance in the future.
2) Subcommittee Evaluation
(1) Audit Committee
• Audit Committee Evaluation (As a Whole) score 100% Excellent Range
• Audit Committee Individual Director Evaluation score 91.22% Excellent Range
The annual performance evaluation of the subcommittees involves evaluating three areas including the structure and qualifications of the committee members, the roles, duties, and responsibilities of the committee, and the committee meetings.
(2) Risk Management Committee
• Risk Management Committee Evaluation (As a Whole) score 100% Excellent Range
• Risk Management Committee Individual Director Evaluation score 87.74% Excellent Range
The annual performance evaluation of the subcommittees involves evaluating three areas including the structure and qualifications of the committee members, the roles, duties, and responsibilities of the committee, and the committee meetings.
Evaluation Results
| Evaluated Body | Group — Carried Out? | Group — Grade / Average Score | Group — Grade / Full Score | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Carried Out? | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Average Score | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Full Score | Cross (Assessing Other Directors) — Carried Out? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Board Of Director | Y | 94.02% | 100% | Y | 93.88% | 100% | N |
| Audit Committee | Y | 100% | 100% | Y | 91.22% | 100% | N |
| Other Subcommittee | Y | 100% | 100% | Y | 87.74 | 100% | N |
Subcommittees
Subcommittees
| Results of the Subcommittee's Duty Performance |
|---|
The Risk Management Committee of Ratchapruek Hospital Public Company Limited has been appointed by the Board of Directors, consisting of 3 members, consisting of 2 independent directors and 1 non-executive director. During 2024, there were 2 Risk Management Committee meetings in total to support the management to operate with maximum efficiency through the Risk Management Committee meetings in total of 2 meetings to consider and screen issues that may have significant impacts in all dimensions. The names of the Risk Management Committee members are as follows: 1. Mr. Suphan Srithamma, Chairman of the Risk Management Committee 2. Mr. Vairoj Jindamaneepitak, Member of Risk Management Committee 3. Mrs. Tina Singhsacha, Member of Risk Management Committee In 2024, the Company realizes the importance of risk management, which is an important foundation for effective management and business operations to achieve the objectives of generating profits and income, and to maintain the interests of stakeholders. The Company has organized enterprise-level risk management and promoted an organizational culture of developing and maintaining risk management policies, Internal Audit, Internal Control and Risk Management. In summary, from the Company's business strategy that focuses on maintaining stability, the key points in the past year are as follows: 1. Set and review the risk management policy throughout the organization, as well as review the Company's risk appetite framework to be consistent with the strategic plan and business direction, including the changing situation affecting the business sector and society worldwide. 2. Provide comments on the preparation of the enterprise risk list for 2024. 3. Support the organization's risk culture by organizing an Enterprise Risk Management training on October 12, 2024, honored by Dr. Narumon Singhaseni as a speaker in the training for the Company's directors and the hospital's risk management working group. Which has fully participated in the training 4. Monitor and analyze various environmental factors that have occurred, the organization's mission, including building confidence in investors and stakeholders of the company. The company has supported and promoted the implementation of risk management in a tangible manner (Tone at the Top) by the board of directors under the operation of the Risk Management Committee (RMC), which is a representative with knowledge and ability from the board of directors to operate under the risk management committee charter and the company's enterprise risk management framework (Enterprise Risk Management: ERM) and in accordance with the risk management guidelines according to the COSO ERM 2017 and ISO 31000:2009 standards. In 2024, the Risk Management Committee continued to emphasize the importance of overseeing enterprise risk management continuously. All members of the Risk Management Committee participated in performing their duties completely in every meeting to create management in various forms, resulting in the company being able to manage the impacts effectively and promptly. This has allowed the company to continue to operate its business according to the strategic plan and maintain its operating results according to the plan, including monitoring, evaluating, and providing recommendations on various investment projects to ensure that the company's business operations will be effective under the framework of acceptable risks. and there is a determination of risk control or mitigation measures (Mitigation Plan) that are tangible and can be put into practice. |
Meeting Attendance & Remuneration
Meeting Attendance — Introduction
Attendance and Compensation of Individual Board Members
1. Board of Directors Meetings
The Board of Directors schedules a minimum of 4 meetings per year, with meeting dates set in advance for the entire year. The Company Secretary is assigned the task of sending the meeting schedule and agenda to the Board in advance, so that members can manage their time and attend the meetings. However, the meeting dates may change depending on the importance of the agenda items that need to be addressed.
In 2024,
- the Board of Directors held a total of 5 out of 5 meetings, with 100% attendance.
- the Audit Committee held 4 out of 4 meetings, with 100% attendance
- Similarly, the Risk Management Committee held 2 out of 2 meetings, with 100% attendance as well.
Furthermore, the Chairman of the Board, CEO, and Independent Lead Director jointly review the topics to be included in the meeting agenda and determine the meeting schedule. In cases where key management members are involved in significant agenda items, they may be assigned to attend Board meetings to provide additional necessary information. The Company Secretary is responsible for sending the meeting invitation letters, along with the supporting documents for the agenda, to the Board at least seven (7) days in advance, ensuring that the Board has enough time to review the materials, unless there is an urgent matter that requires immediate attention.
Justification for Directors' Non-Attendance
1) Ms. Sirikul Laukaikul has the right to attend 4 meetings, but was only able to attend 3 of the meetings due to illness. She therefore submitted a letter to the Chairman of the Board to request leave for the meeting.
2) Mrs. Tina Singhsacha has the right to attend 4 meetings, but was only able to attend 3 of the meetings due to illness. Therefore, he submitted a letter to the Chairman of the Board requesting leave from the meeting to abroad.
Remuneration — Introduction
Compensation Policy and Structure for Directors and Subcommittees
The Board of Directors ensures that the compensation structure and rates for directors and subcommittee members are appropriate, considering their duties, responsibilities, Company performance, and business size. Compensation levels are benchmarked against companies of similar size in the same industry. Shareholders approve the compensation structure and rates, both monetary and non-monetary, and the Company discloses its compensation policy and amounts in its annual report.
1.Director Compensation
(1) Monetary Compensation Meeting allowances Monthly compensation Annual Bonus
(2) Non-Monetary Compensation The Company provides non-monetary benefits to Board members as per the agreement, including medical benefits and annual health check-ups for directors and their families, with a limit of THB 300,000 per person per year.
Note: All monetary and non-monetary compensation was approved at the Annual General Meeting (AGM) on April 22, 2024.
Details of Director Compensation in 2024
For 2024, the Company paid a monthly compensation to directors, within the approved limit of THB 3,000,000. For director bonuses in 2024, the Company set a maximum budget of 2% of dividend payments, capped at THB 1,800,000, to be distributed among 10 directors.
As of December 31, 2024, the Company had one subsidiary, Kaen pa-nga Co., Ltd.,
which had not yet commenced operations and was undergoing a capital increase review. Therefore, no compensation was paid to the subsidiary’s directors.
2. Executive Compensation
The Company determines executive compensation based on performance evaluations, aligning with both Company performance and individual achievements. Annual performance appraisals are conducted, and the CEO evaluates the appropriateness of executive compensation and annual salary adjustments to reflect each executive's performance and responsibilities under the Company’s vision, mission, and strategy.
The CEO’s compensation is set by the Board of Directors based on transparent, fair, and reasonable criteria, considering responsibilities, performance, short-term and long-term incentives, and Company financial results compared to business plans. The Board also evaluates the CEO’s performance annually to ensure alignment with the Company’s strategic direction and mission.
Monetary Compensation for Executives (Excluding Compensation as Directors)
The Company provides executive compensation, which includes salary, position allowance, bonus, provident fund contributions, social security contributions, and other benefits. The Company determines executive compensation based on knowledge, expertise, experience, and Company performance, while also benchmarking against companies in the same industry.
Non-Monetary Compensation for Executives
At Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2024, held on Saturday, February 17, 2024, the Board reviewed and approved non-monetary compensation for executives, including medical benefits and annual health check-ups, with a budget of THB 150,000 per person per year.
Note: In 2024, the Board of Directors reviewed the medical and health check-up benefits for executives and resolved to maintain the existing benefits.
Types of Remuneration of the Board of Directors
The Company has established a compensation policy for directors and executives that aligns with its long-term strategies and goals. Compensation is set at a competitive level comparable to the industry to attract and retain high-quality directors and executives.
Director compensation is divided into these two categories. (1) Monetary compensation and (2) Non-monetary compensation
1.Monetary compensation includes board meeting fees, director gratuities, and annual bonuses.
2. Non-monetary compensation includes healthcare benefits and annual medical check-ups for directors and their families.
Both forms of compensation must be approved by the shareholders’ meeting.
Remuneration Directors
In 2024, the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders resolved to approve the director remuneration as follows:
1. Monthly fee of the Board (Monthly) The Chairman and all directors will receive a remuneration of 15,000 baht/person/month (the same amount for all).
2. Meeting allowances fee of Sub-committee (only the directors who attend the meeting)
are approved as a limit, with each payment and position as follows:
- Chairman of the Board of Directors, 14,400 baht/meeting
- Member of the Board of Directors, 12,000 baht/meeting
- Chairman of all subcommittees will receive a meeting allowance of 14,400 baht/person/meeting
- Each subcommittee will receive a meeting allowance of 12,000 baht/person/times/meeting
3. Annual bonus, 2 percent of dividend payment, but not exceeding 1,800,000 baht, which the Board of Directors will consider allocating among themselves
Other Remuneration : - None -
Remuneration or Benefits Payable to the Board
| Metric | Amount (Baht) |
|---|---|
| Remunerations or benefits pending payment to the board of directors over the past year (baht) | 0 |
Supervision of Subsidiaries & Associated Companies
Does the Company Have Subsidiaries or Associated Companies?
Yes
Is There a Mechanism for Overseeing Subsidiaries and Associated Companies?
Yes
Mechanism for Overseeing Management of Subsidiaries
Governance of Subsidiaries and Affiliates
The Company has one subsidiary, Kaen Pa Nga Co., Ltd. (Kaen Pa Nga). To protect the investment interests and ensure that the subsidiary operates in compliance with relevant laws, regulations, and criteria, and to manage the operations in alignment with the Company's policies effectively and efficiently, the Company has established a governance policy for the operations of its subsidiaries and affiliates.
1. The Company send its representatives to serve as directors in each subsidiary and/or affiliate in proportion to its shareholding. The representatives who serve as directors must be considered and approved by the Board of Directors, taking into account the appropriateness for each Company. T
2. The directors of the subsidiary and/or affiliate appointed by the Company are responsible for overseeing these matters.
o Overseeing the subsidiary's and/or affiliate's business operations to ensure they align with the approved business policies, goals, strategies, and plans.
o Attending meetings and casting votes at the board meetings of the subsidiary and/or affiliate on important matters related to the business operations of the subsidiary and/or affiliate.
o Ensuring that the subsidiary and/or affiliate has an effective internal control system and risk management system that is adequate and robust. o Ensuring that the subsidiary and/or affiliate complies with announcements and guidelines regarding transactions or operations that fall under asset acquisitions or disposals and related-party transactions, as per the criteria of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Securities and Exchange Commission. Additionally, ensuring the subsidiary and/or affiliate discloses financial status, operating performance, related-party transactions, asset acquisitions or disposals, and other significant transactions, such as capital increases, capital reductions, or Company dissolution
3. If a subsidiary and/or affiliate is involved in any transactions that require the Company to disclose information to the Stock Exchange of Thailand as per the prescribed criteria, the subsidiary and/or affiliate must immediately notify the Company's management as soon as they are aware that such a transaction or event will occur.
Oversight Mechanisms
| Mechanism |
|---|
| Defining the scope of powers, duties and responsibilities of directors and executives who represent the company in setting important policies |
| Internal control system of the subsidiary operating the core business is appropriate and sufficient in the subsidiary operating the core business |
| Acquisition or disposal of assets |
| Other important transactions |
| Transactions between the Company and related persons |
| Disclosure of financial information and operating results |
Agreements Between the Company and Shareholders in Managing Subsidiaries
As of December 31, 2024, the Company has no shareholders’ agreement regarding the management of subsidiaries and associates.
Board Duty Performance — Overview
Board Duty Performance — Overall Description
The Board of Directors places importance on compliance with the principles of good corporate governance, which is an important foundation for developing and creating sustainable business value, in addition to building confidence among investors, in order to lead to competitive business operations with good performance, taking into account long-term impacts, conducting business ethically, respecting the rights and being responsible to shareholders and stakeholders, benefiting society, developing or reducing negative impacts on the environment, being able to adapt to changing factors, and requiring annual reviews in line with the Company's business direction, so that all directors, executives and employees of the Company are aware of and adhere to as guidelines for their operations, as disclosed in the annual report (Form 56-1 One Report).
In the past year 2024, the five independent directors did not have any business relationships or provide professional services in excess of the specified criteria. The five independent directors met the specified criteria, which did not affect their duties and independent opinions.
Audit Committee Duty Performance
Results of the Audit Committee's Duty Performance in the Past Year
Report on the Performance of the Audit Committee
Presented to the Shareholders of Ratchaphruek Hospital Public Company Limited
The Audit Committee has carried out its duties within the scope, responsibilities, and obligations as defined in the charter approved by the Board of Directors, which is in compliance with the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
The Audit Committee has performed its duties independently and impartially, adhering to the scope set out in the Audit Committee Charter, which is reviewed annually to ensure its alignment with the current situation and approved by the Board of Directors. Additionally, the Audit Committee has supported fostering a strong organizational culture based on corporate governance, ethics, integrity, accountability, and transparency for the long-term sustainability of the organization.
During the fiscal year 2024, the Audit Committee held a total of 4 meetings, with all committee members attending every session. One of these meetings was a joint session between the Audit Committee and the external auditors, with no management representatives present.
Main Duties of the Audit Committee
1) Financial Statements
The Audit Committee has reviewed and considered the quarterly and consolidated financial statements of Ratchaphruek Hospital Public Company Limited and its subsidiaries for the year ending December 31, 2024, together with the management and the Company's auditors. These statements are in accordance with Thai Financial Reporting Standards (TFRS) and consistent with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). The Audit Committee has discussed the accuracy and completeness of the financial statements and the disclosures therein with the auditors, as well as any material accounting adjustments affecting the financial statements, the scope of the audit, the adequacy of accounting methods, and the assessment of the internal controls. This was to ensure compliance with financial reporting standards and benefit the users of the financial statements. Additionally, the Audit Committee met with the auditors without Company management present to discuss the scope, approach, and audit plans for the quarterly and annual audits, to inquire about potential risks or irregularities identified during the audit, and to assess whether there were any signs of fraud. In summary, the auditors had no concerns and found no indications of any events that could affect the financial statements.
2) Related Party Transactions
The Audit Committee has reviewed the disclosure of related party transactions and those that could potentially involve conflicts of interest, ensuring that they were conducted on normal business terms, with transparency, and with sufficient disclosure, as would be the case with transactions with third parties. These transactions were properly reviewed and disclosed to the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) in a timely manner.
3) Internal Control and Risk Management
The Audit Committee has reviewed internal audit reports and the progress of operations on a quarterly basis, according to the approved plan. The review scope included key areas of business importance and the effectiveness of organizational operations and the continuous improvement of internal controls through training and awareness for employees and management. The Audit Committee has considered and was satisfied with the improvements made following the internal audit report recommendations, concluding that the Company’s internal control systems are adequate and appropriate for the business operations, in line with the auditor’s view that there are no material weaknesses that could impact the Company’s financial statements. Finally, the Audit Committee reviewed and approved the annual audit plan for 2025, including the budget to support the audit activities in accordance with the plan.
4) Compliance with Laws
The Audit Committee has reviewed the Company’s compliance with securities and exchange laws, regulations from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and other relevant laws affecting the Company’s operations. The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Company complies with all relevant laws and has found no significant issues.
5) Selection and Appointment of Auditors
The Audit Committee recommended the appointment of Mr. Prawit Wiwanthananut and/or Ms. Chutima Wongsarapanchai and/or Mr. Boonkasem Sarnklin and/or Ms.Jiamjai Saengsi from PV Audit Co., Ltd. as the Company’s auditors for 2024. The committee also considered the audit fees, which will be presented to the Board of Directors for approval and subsequently proposed for shareholder approval at the Annual General Meeting (AGM) of 2025.
6) Good Corporate Governance
The Company emphasizes managing operations according to good corporate governance principles. The Audit Committee has ensured adequate and accurate disclosure of information and promoted the Company’s governance and management systems to maintain transparency and ethics, fostering trust among shareholders, investors, employees, and all stakeholders. The committee also reviewed the process for reporting conflicts of interest among directors and executives to ensure compliance with the Securities and Exchange Act.
In summary, the Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Company’s financial statements have been prepared in accordance with financial reporting standards, related party transactions were conducted on reasonable business terms with transparency and sufficient disclosure, the risk management and internal control systems are adequate and effective, and the Company has fully complied with the relevant regulations.

